Cover Page

Another Economy is Possible

Culture and Economy in a Time of Crisis

Manuel Castells
Sarah Banet-Weiser
Sviatlana Hlebik
Giorgos Kallis
Sarah Pink
Kirsten Seale
Lisa J. Servon
Lana Swartz
Angelos Varvarousis









polity

About the Authors

Sarah Banet-Weiser is Professor and Director of the Annenberg School for Communication at the University of Southern California (USC), Los Angeles. She is also Professor in the School of Communication, and in the Department of American Studies and Ethnicity at USC. Her teaching and research interests include feminist theory, race and the media, youth culture, popular and consumer culture, and citizenship and national identity. She teaches courses in culture and communication, gender and media, youth culture, feminist theory and cultural studies, including economic cultures. She is the author of the award-winning book Authentic™ (2014).

Manuel Castells is University Professor and the Wallis Annenberg Chair in Communication Technology and Society at the University of Southern California (USC), Los Angeles. He is also Professor Emeritus, University of California, Berkeley, where he was Professor of City and Regional Planning and Professor of Sociology from 1979 to 2003 before joining USC. In addition, he is a Professor of Sociology at the Open University of Catalonia, and a Fellow of St. John’s College, University of Cambridge. He holds the Chair on the Network Society at the Collège d’études mondiales, Fondation Maison des sciences de l’homme, Paris.

Sviatlana Hlebik holds a PhD in Economic Policy, MS in Finance and Risk Management, and MSc in Economic Cybernetics. She is the author of works on monetary policy, banking, and alternative economic practices during the financial crisis. She currently conducts research on bank regulation. She works in the Financial Management Directorate, Cariparma Crédit Agricole, Parma, Italy.

Giorgos Kallis is an environmental scientist working on ecological economics and political ecology. He is a Leverhulme visiting professor at SOAS and an ICREA professor at ICTA, Autonomous University of Barcelona. Before that he was a Marie Curie International Fellow at the Energy and Resources Group of the University of California at Berkeley. He holds a PhD in Environmental Policy and Planning from the University of the Aegean in Greece, a Masters in Economics from Universitat Pompeu Fabra, and a Masters in Environmental Engineering and a Bachelors in Chemistry from Imperial College, London.

Sarah Pink is RMIT Distinguished Professor in Design and Media Ethnography, and Director of the Digital Ethnography Research Centre at the Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology. She is also Visiting Professor at Halmstad University (Sweden) and Loughborough University (UK) and Guest Professor at Free University Berlin (Germany). Her recent collaborative books include Digital Materialities (2016), Digital Ethnography (2016), Screen Ecologies (2016), Media, Anthropology and Public Engagement (2015), and the iBook Un/certainty (2015). She is the sole author of Doing Sensory Ethnography, 2nd edition (2015).

Kirsten Seale is senior researcher at the University of Western Sydney. Her current research interest focuses on informal urban street markets. She has examined how informal urban street markets facilitate the informal and formal economy not merely in terms of the traditional concerns of labor and consumption, but also in regards to cultural and spatial contingencies. Seale examines what these markets reveal about urban life in a time of globalized, rapid urbanization and flows of people, knowledge, and goods.

Lisa J. Servon is Professor and former Dean at the Milano School of International Affairs, Management, and Urban Policy, New School University, New York. Professor Servon holds a BA in Political Science from Bryn Mawr College, an MA in History of Art from the University of Pennsylvania, and a PhD in Urban Planning from the University of California, Berkeley. She teaches in the Urban Policy Program at the Milano School and conducts research in the areas of urban poverty, community development, economic development, and issues of gender and race.

Lana Swartz is a post-doctoral researcher in the Social Media Collective of Microsoft Research in New England. In fall 2016, she will join the faculty of the University of Virginia as an assistant professor of Media Studies. She is working on a book on money as communication, both as a form of information transmission and as a vector of relations, memory, and culture.

Angelos Varvarousis is a researcher based in Barcelona, at the Universitat Autonoma de Barcelona. He is a member in the Research and Development group of Barcelona, with a focus primarily on alternative economic practices in Greece.

Acknowledgments

This volume presents the results of the study undertaken by a collaborative international research network on alternative economic practices and their cultural foundations that investigated and met between 2011 and 2015. The annual meetings of the network took place in 2011–12 in Barcelona, at the Open University of Catalonia, and in 2013–15 in Paris, at the Collège d’études mondiales, Fondation Maison des sciences de l’homme.

The project was funded by the Collège d’études mondiales. The authors want to express their gratitude to Professor Michel Wieviorka, President of the Fondation Maison des sciences de l’homme, and to Dr Olivier Bouin, Director of the Collège d’études mondiales, for their intellectual encouragement and material support provided to the project over three years.

We also want to thank Mr Gilles Desfeux, of the Fondation Maison des sciences de l’homme, for his care in organizing our annual meetings in Paris, and Mr Jean Louis Cury, director of the Maison Suger, Fondation de la Maison des sciences de l’homme, for his hospitality in hosting our meetings in the historic venue of the Maison Suger.

The meetings in Barcelona in 2011–12 were organized by Ms. Noelia Diaz Lopez, from the Internet Interdisciplinary Institute of the Open University of Catalonia.

The coordination of the project was assured by Ms. Pauline Martinez, and by Ms. Reanna Martinez, at the Annenberg School of Communication, University of Southern California, Los Angeles. We thank them for their support.

Introduction

Manuel Castells

This volume emerged from the challenge to rethink the meaning of economic practices in the wake of the financial crisis of 2008 and beyond. While governments and financial elites reacted to the near collapse of financial capitalism by attempting to restore the conditions of business as usual, the economic, social, and human damage inflicted by the crisis prompted a reconsideration of the inevitability of unfettered capitalism as a fact of life. A number of economic practices appeared throughout Europe and the United States that embodied alternative values: the value of life over the value of money; the effectiveness of cooperation over cutthroat competition; the social responsibility of corporations and responsible regulation by governments over the short-term financial strategies, led by greed rather than long-term profit-making, that took the overall economy to the brink of catastrophe. From Spain to Greece, from the US to Australia, and to many other countries beyond our direct observation, we saw the blossoming of multiple experiences of innovation in organizing work and life: cooperatives, barter networks, ethical banking, community currencies, time sharing banks, alternative means of payment, etc., that paved the way for a fast-developing sharing economy in all domains of activities oriented toward the satisfaction of human needs. Furthermore, while some of these new economic practices appear to be a reaction to the inability of the standard economic operations to provide goods, services, and credit during the crisis, other innovations became increasingly visible when taking a broader look at the way economic transactions co-evolve with culture, technology, and institutions in a fast-changing society. This is the case with cryptographic virtual currencies, epitomized by bitcoin, which blended a libertarian, entrepreneurial spirit with information technology to provide an alternative to standard forms of currency. In a very different vein, this is also the case of forms of banking for those at the bottom of the pyramid, who are creating a financial underworld with its own rules and effects – an underworld that can only be understood through the methods of participant observation that inform some of the work presented in this volume.

Yet, this is not a collection of diverse case studies. Because throughout our collaborative research and in this volume, there is a common theme that provides the link to our polyhedric observation. There are as many economic practices as there are cultures. If standardized forms of capitalism appear to provide uniformity to economic practices it is only because of the cultural domination of capitalism, of the different forms of capitalism, enforced by institutions whose rules result from power struggles institutionalized in the law – always in flux. Thus, when standardized economic practices do not mesh with people’s practices, either because they cannot practice them in situations of crisis, or because they challenge the values embodied in financial capitalism, alternative economic practices appear. These are not necessarily anti-capitalist (bitcoin is not), but different from current capitalism. At the source of this observation is our common statement. The economy is not simply related to culture: economy is culture. Looking at a whole range of economic practices, some directly observed, others studied more broadly from a cultural perspective (such as feminist economics or ecological economics), we can understand the logic of social change at the heart of the economic system. If economy is culture and if cultures are diverse and often contradictory, a whole range of economic practices are equally relevant and equally able to organize the way people produce, consume, exchange, innovate, invest, and live. This is the terrain we explored for three years in our research network, moving freely between observation, quantitative analysis, theory, and practice. This is our project: to unveil the cultural foundation of all economic practices by focusing on those that, because they are “alternative” (to contemporary financial capitalism), make more visible the cultural content of their economic logic. We have constructed an argument, not just collected a number of research papers and theoretical elaborations. Our argument is this: economic practices are human practices that, as such, are determined by humans who embody their ways of being and thinking, their interests, their values, their projects. There is no abstract, inevitable economic logic outside human practice, a metaphysical, a-historical logic to which humans should conform. If they do, it is because they are compelled or induced to resignation. When they are not, they redefine the goals and means of their economic practices, as in all dimensions of their practices. There is no such thing as a non-human economy. There is, yes, an inhuman economy because it sometimes benefits certain humans who try to appropriate humanity as a whole for their own advantage until other humans think differently, practice differently, and end up creating alternative forms of production, consumption, and exchange. This is our story, the story of this book, told in a plurality of voices, but in the harmony of a shared intellectual purpose.

Paris, Barcelona, New York, Athens, Parma, Boston, Melbourne, Los Angeles
January 2016